Chapter 5 - The Notary With Shaking Hands

Kevin returned with an attorney the next day and gave a much fuller statement.
He admitted that when Elaine first called, he nearly declined because same-night notarizations involving family property transfers were a professional red flag. But she offered extra money and said the bride’s lawyer was “being overly dramatic,” so he agreed.
Then he arrived and saw the belt on the floor.
Saw Derek breathing hard.
Saw me in boxing gloves.
Saw unsigned papers spread across a bed like a trap.
And still, he froze.
“I should’ve walked out the second I understood,” he said.
He was right.
But he didn’t lie, and that mattered.
His account matched the footage and my audio recording. Better still, the documents he brought had originated from a downtown document-prep office that kept electronic intake records. Those records included the email address used to order the packet.
Elaine’s.
The package also included specimen signatures—my name written over and over for “consistency.”
Derek had not brought me home to get my signature.
He had brought me home to make a forged one look voluntary.
The prosecutor assigned to the case became visibly more interested after that.
By the end of the week, Derek and Elaine were facing potential charges for attempted coercion, criminal forgery, and conspiracy. Their lawyers immediately shifted tone. Suddenly, I was no longer unstable. I was “misinterpreting intense family conflict.”
That phrase alone made me want to hit something.
Luis let me work the heavy bag after hours until my shoulders shook.
When I got home—if the gym loft could be called home by then—Mara was waiting with takeout and another question.
“Did Derek ever ask you to introduce him to vendors or managers connected to the properties?”
I thought about it.
“Yes. More than once.”
“Did you?”
“No. I always told him I wanted to wait.”
Mara nodded like I had just confirmed a theory.
Then she showed me three emails that had arrived from separate property managers over the past six weeks. Each one mentioned brief contact from Derek asking “casual questions” about rent rolls, reserve accounts, and insurance carriers because he was “helping Elena step back from the burden.”
None of them had replied with anything useful because Mara had warned them months earlier to route all unusual requests through counsel.
I looked up sharply.
“Why did you warn them months earlier?”
May you like
She met my eyes.
“Because the first time Derek asked about control, I started paying attention.”