Chapter 5 - EVELYN’S FIRST BABY

Evelyn had once had a daughter.
I knew that vaguely.
Mark's older sister.
Lydia.
She died before he was old enough to remember her.
In our eight years of marriage, Mark mentioned her perhaps three times.
The story was always short.
Lydia had severe eczema.
She developed an infection.
She died at five months old.
The tragedy drove Evelyn into infant skincare research.
It became the origin story of the entire family.
Grief turned into purpose.
Purpose turned into a company.
The company was eventually sold, but Evelyn's patents and reputation funded the family foundation.
At charity dinners, photographs of baby Lydia appeared on screens.
Because Every Child Deserves Comfort.
That sentence suddenly felt different.
Detective Cole called Mark in for another interview after investigators matched Subject 1's birth date.
Lydia Hale.
His sister.
The first subject in Evelyn's notebook was her own daughter.
Mark called me afterward.
I almost didn't answer.
Then did.
“Did you know?”
“No.”
His voice sounded strange.
Small.
“What does the notebook say?”
“Police won't give me everything.”
“Mark.”
“They said the sessions begin three weeks before she was hospitalized.”
I sat down.
“Your mother tested something on Lydia?”
“It looks that way.”
“Could it have caused her death?”
“I don't know.”
That question remained medically difficult.
Nearly three decades had passed.
The old hospital records documented extensive dermatitis and a serious infection.
They did not document an experimental topical product.
No physician had apparently been told.
Evelyn had always said Lydia's skin disease became severe despite standard treatment.
The notebook suggested another possibility.
Not proof.
Possibility.
Mark sounded as though the ground beneath his childhood had disappeared.
“My mother told me she invented the first formula because Lydia died.”
“What if she used it before?”
“I know.”
“No.”
I hated how hard my voice became.
“You need to understand something.”
“What?”
“If your mother hurt Lydia, then built a career around the story that she created her work afterward, your whole family has been living inside a lie.”
He went silent.
The following week, investigators located Subject 2.
A woman now twenty-seven named April Monroe.
Her parents had worked with Evelyn at the small cosmetics laboratory where she began her career.
April had no memory of any experiment.
Her mother did.
She had believed Evelyn was applying an approved barrier lotion developed by their employer.
After April developed a rash, Evelyn told the family the child was sensitive to preservatives.
Nothing more happened.
Subject 3 could not yet be identified.
Then came the twenty-year gap.
Whatever Evelyn had been doing stopped.
Why?
The answer may have been Thomas.
Mark's father.
Investigators found a locked file cabinet in his old study.
Inside were copies of letters he had never mailed.
One was addressed to Evelyn.
Dated twenty-seven years earlier.
The first line read:
I will not let you use Mark the way you used Lydia.
Mark stared at the copy for a long time.
Then asked Detective Cole:
“What does my name have to do with this?”
Cole did not answer immediately.
She turned another page.
May you like
Subject 3's initials were M.H.
The birth date belonged to my husband.