chronicore

Chapter 3 - SIX CHILDREN, TWENTY-EIGHT YEARS

The notebook did not contain six recent victims.

That was the first major correction.

Forensic examiners photographed each page before investigators began matching initials to dates.

The oldest entry was twenty-eight years old.

The newest, before Sophie, was eighteen months old.

Evelyn had not been conducting one continuous hidden study.

She had been returning to the same idea across decades.

That somehow felt worse.

Subject 1.

Subject 2.

Subject 3.

Then a gap of almost twenty years.

Subjects 4, 5, 6.

Sophie was 7.

The language changed across time.

Early pages looked like laboratory shorthand.

Later entries sounded almost personal.

Mother anxious.

Father overreactive.

Continue despite redness?

Family refused second visit.

One entry ended:

REMOVED BY MOTHER.

Detective Cole would not tell me names until identities were confirmed.

That was appropriate.

It also drove me crazy.

Evelyn retained an attorney and stopped speaking.

Her lawyer described the incident as “a tragic misunderstanding involving an experimental but non-toxic topical preparation.”

My attorney, Meredith Sloan, read that statement aloud.

“Experimental and newborn should not appear in the same sentence without consent paperwork.”

“Can she actually call it research?”

“She can call a toaster research. That doesn't make it a lawful study.”

Meredith was forty-nine, divorced twice, and incapable of pretending uncertainty was confidence.

I liked her immediately.

She warned me against reading internet comments.

I read them anyway.

Some people said Evelyn was obviously insane.

Others said I had overreacted because grandmothers used home remedies for generations.

One person asked why I had left my baby alone with someone I clearly distrusted.

That one stayed with me.

I turned off my phone.

Sophie came home three days later.

Not to the house Mark and I shared.

To my sister Claire's.

Mark objected only once.

“I'm her father.”

“Yes.”

“I should be with her.”

“You can see her when I am comfortable and when the attorneys agree.”

“You think I'm dangerous?”

“I don't know what you are yet.”

He looked as though I had cut him.

Maybe I had.

Marriage creates a strange confidence.

You do not merely trust what your spouse has told you.

You trust that there are entire categories of things they would never hide.

When that collapses, even harmless memories become evidence.

Why had Mark insisted his mother attend every baby shower?

Why had Evelyn asked about Sophie's skin before asking about her weight?

Why had Mark become tense when I rejected the homemade lotion Evelyn brought after delivery?

Which moments were ordinary?

Which ones had I misunderstood?

That night Detective Cole called.

They had identified Subject 6.

A boy named Oliver Grant.

Eighteen months earlier.

His mother had agreed to speak.

Her name was Dana Grant.

Before ending the call, Cole said:

“There’s something you should know before you meet her.”

“What?”

“Your husband already knows Dana.”

I sat up.

“How?”

“He contacted her after her child’s reaction.”

I closed my eyes.

Mark had told me he knew about one historical problem.

Now there was a living mother.

May you like

A recent baby.

And a conversation he had somehow forgotten to mention.

Related Stories

Other posts