Chapter 12 - THE FATHER THEY HAD NEVER MET

Grief entered the girls differently.
Emma wanted photographs.
All of them.
Sophie wanted stories.
Constantly.
Lily became angry.
At Claire.
At me.
At Ethan.
“He should've told somebody.”
“He tried,” Claire said.
“He should've tried harder.”
There was no useful adult correction.
Anger does not obey chronology.
One night Lily asked:
“If Daddy had come home, would Mommy still have gone on the date with Adrian?”
Claire almost choked on tea.
I looked away.
Lily was relentless.
“Well?”
“No,” Claire said.
That answer hurt.
Which meant it was probably necessary.
The blind date did not magically erase Ethan.
Claire had loved him.
Planned a life with him.
Raised his daughters alone while believing he abandoned her.
Learning the truth did not convert old love into a convenient stepping-stone toward me.
For several months, Claire and I did not date.
We investigated.
Grieved.
Argued.
Raised questions neither of us owned.
I visited the girls because they asked.
Not because biology gave me any claim.
I brought Ethan's old college photographs.
One showed him asleep during an economics lecture.
Sophie laughed for two minutes.
Then:
“Did he snore?”
“Violently.”
Claire smiled.
A real smile.
Later, she told me:
“That was the first story about him they heard that wasn't sad.”
I understood why that mattered.
The girls' father could not become only:
dead whistleblower.
victim.
missing man.
He had hated mustard.
Collected terrible vinyl records.
Cheated at Monopoly.
Once spent an entire night helping me find a dog I had hit with my car because I was twenty-one and convinced I had killed it.
We found the dog sleeping under a porch.
Ethan cried harder than I did.
The girls loved that story.
Then Emma asked:
“Are you going to be our dad now?”
The room went still.
I crouched so we were eye level.
“No.”
Her face fell.
I continued.
“I'm Adrian.”
She waited.
“If one day our relationship becomes something important to you, you get to decide what you call it.”
Sophie considered this.
“Can we still interview you?”
“Apparently I have no choice.”
Lily opened the pink notebook.
May you like
“You're improving.”
That was the first time Claire laughed at me without guilt.