Chapter 14 - THE FIRST LETTER FROM PRISON

Rebecca did not write for eighteen months.
Then one letter arrived through her attorney.
Addressed to Natalie.
Not Eli.
Natalie left it unopened for three weeks.
Finally she called me.
“Why am I asking my former home-health nurse what to do with my sister's prison letter?”
“Poor boundaries?”
She laughed.
That was progress.
Then she became serious.
“Do I owe her an answer?”
“No.”
“Do I owe myself reading it?”
“That's your question.”
She hated when I returned responsibility to her.
Eventually she opened it.
Rebecca wrote about therapy.
About grief.
About the difference between being genetically related to a child and being entitled to parent that child.
She did not ask to see Eli.
She did not ask Natalie to visit.
She wrote:
I spent years believing that because I helped create something precious, I had earned a permanent claim on it. I understand now that gifts stop being gifts when we use them as receipts.
Natalie cried.
Then laughed angrily at herself for crying.
Ben sat beside her.
He did not tell her what the tears meant.
That was part of his growth.
Rebecca ended with one request.
Not contact.
Not forgiveness.
She wanted Natalie to tell Eli, when he was old enough, that the egg donation began in love.
Natalie reread that sentence.
“What do you think?” Ben asked.
“I think she's asking me to protect one part of her story.”
“Will you?”
Natalie looked toward Eli playing on the living-room rug.
“I don't know.”
That was allowed.
A year later, Rebecca became eligible for supervised correspondence.
Natalie did not agree immediately.
She met with a child therapist.
Her attorney.
Ben.
Then made one decision.
Rebecca could send one letter each year.
The letters would be stored unopened until Natalie and professionals believed Eli was old enough to decide whether he wanted them.
Rebecca agreed.
No protest.
May you like
No demand to know when.
For the first time since Eli's birth, she accepted a boundary whose timetable belonged entirely to someone else.