chronicore

Chapter 12 - Brenda Asked to See Ethan, Not Noah

Six months after the incident, Brenda requested a mediated meeting.

Not with Noah.

Ethan.

He almost refused.

Then agreed.

I did not attend.

He told me afterward.

Brenda looked different.

Medication for sleep.

Therapy.

No makeup.

No performance of strength.

She began:

“I was wrong.”

Ethan said:

“That doesn't cover it.”

“No.”

Good beginning.

She did not say:

I was tired.

Though she was.

She did not say:

Your relapse caused this.

Though it shaped everything.

She said:

“I hurt him because I wanted the crying to stop.”

Then:

“I hurt Ava because she saw me become somebody I thought I hated.”

Ethan asked:

“Our mother?”

Their mother.

Brenda nodded.

That sentence mattered because admitting resemblance is different from explaining it away.

Then she said:

“You asked me not to give Noah back when you were unsafe.”

“Yes.”

“I kept hearing that sentence after you became safe.”

“Yes.”

“I didn't know when protecting him became punishing you.”

Ethan replied:

“I think you did.”

She looked down.

“Maybe.”

That was more honest.

Then:

“I liked being the one Lauren trusted.”

He said nothing.

“I liked being the person everybody needed.”

Nothing.

“And when you got better, I was going to be Brenda again.”

“What does that mean?”

She laughed bitterly.

“Exactly.”

At thirteen she was mother.

At sixteen protector.

At forty-five, after Lauren died, she became mother again.

Without that role she did not know what remained.

Ethan said:

“You could have been his aunt.”

Brenda cried.

“I know.”

That was perhaps the saddest line.

May you like

Not because it erased what she did.

Because she had destroyed a smaller, healthier relationship while trying to keep a bigger one that was never hers.

Related Stories

Other posts