Chapter 8 - David Was Afraid of Losing More Than His Marriage

David's father, Robert Mercer, had been harsh.
Not physically brutal by the standards David used when telling stories.
Which was its own warning.
Belts.
Forced kneeling.
Food withheld.
Humiliation.
David described it as discipline.
Margaret described Robert as:
“Strong.”
Robert died when David was twenty-three.
For years, David insisted he would parent differently.
In some ways, he did.
He never used a belt.
Never struck Lily.
Until the laundry room, I had relied on that distinction too heavily.
Control can change form.
David tracked Lily's screen use minute by minute.
Made her repeat apologies until he considered them sincere.
Forced her to restart chores if she sighed.
His rules were clean.
Measured.
Defensible one by one.
Together, they taught Lily that his emotional comfort mattered more than hers.
I had pushed back.
Not enough.
That became part of my responsibility.
Then Ruiz uncovered a consultation David had with a family-law attorney.
Not his current criminal lawyer.
Four weeks earlier.
He asked:
Could postpartum mental-health history affect custody?
What evidence supports an emergency custody petition?
What if a parent keeps hazardous substances accessible?
Can a grandparent provide an affidavit regarding instability?
How quickly can a child be prevented from leaving the county?
There it was.
But still:
Consulting a lawyer is not a crime.
Preparing for custody litigation is not evidence of planned harm.
Then came the question that changed the meeting.
David had asked:
“What if the child is injured while in the unstable parent's care?”
The attorney responded in writing:
Any actual safety incident would be evaluated in context. Do not manufacture evidence or create risk to the child.
The lawyer had written that sentence without being prompted by anything investigators had yet found.
May you like
Why?
Because something about David's questions had made even his own attorney uncomfortable.
Related Stories