Chapter 2 - The Ranch That Wanted My Water

My land was not impressive by Dunmore standards.
One hundred and sixty acres.
Forty-two under cultivation.
A garden.
Two milk cows.
Seven hens who regarded fences as philosophical suggestions.
One mule.
One small house James and I had built badly and loved anyway.
But the north quarter bordered Sutter Creek.
That made it valuable.
Not because of gold.
Water.
In Idaho Territory, water could make worthless dirt productive and productive dirt worth fighting over.
James filed our diversion claim years earlier.
A narrow ditch carried creek water into our lower field before continuing west toward Dunmore grazing land.
Silas Dunmore had more cattle than I had fence posts.
During good years, nobody cared much.
During dry years, everybody cared.
The spring after James died, Dunmore offered to buy the north forty acres.
I refused.
He raised the price.
I refused again.
Then he offered for the entire homestead.
I stopped answering.
People in town thought I was foolish.
Maybe I was.
But I had buried my husband beneath a cottonwood on that property.
Lily had taken her first steps across the kitchen floor.
James's handprints were still in the mortar beside the chimney because he had leaned against it before the lime dried.
Some things have a market value.
That does not mean the market gets them.
Two days after the wagon incident, Weston rode to my place.
He stopped outside the gate and waited.
I was hanging laundry.
“You planning to stand there all afternoon?”
“Didn't want to trespass.”
That was new.
“What do you want?”
“To look at the north boundary.”
“No.”
“All right.”
He turned his horse.
I hated that too.
“Wait.”
He stopped.
“Why?”
“Why what?”
“Why do you want to see it?”
“Dunmore says his cattle have lawful access to the lower watering bend.”
“They do not.”
“He says James agreed.”
My stomach tightened.
“My husband agreed to nothing.”
Weston studied me.
“Then I need to know that.”
“You work for Dunmore.”
“Yes.”
“That means you do what he tells you.”
“No.”
The answer came too quickly for arrogance.
I folded a sheet.
“What does foreman mean where you come from?”
“That I'm paid to keep cattle alive and employees from doing stupid things.”
“Does Dunmore count as an employee?”
“No.”
“Pity.”
That time Weston did smile.
I should have disliked it.
I did not.
I let him inspect the boundary.
Three marker stones had been shifted roughly eight feet east.
Not enough to steal a field.
Enough to change where the old ditch crossed during high water.
“Could cattle move them?”
“No.”
“Flood?”
“Maybe one.”
“All three?”
He shook his head.
Someone had moved them.
Recently.
Weston replaced none.
That surprised me.
“You aren't fixing them?”
“Not until we know where they belong.”
“I know where they belong.”
“Then show me evidence.”
I almost ordered him off my property.
Instead I heard James in my memory.
Being right is not the same as being able to prove it, Nora.
I hated when dead husbands remained useful.
Inside the house, I found James's old survey map.
Weston studied it.
Then pointed at one faint notation near Sutter Creek.
Shared seasonal channel — D.
“What is that?”
“I don't know.”
“Dunmore?”
“No.”
“You certain?”
I looked at him.
“No.”
Lily climbed onto the chair between us.
“Papa wrote tiny when he was hiding things.”
I turned.
“What?”
She shrugged.
“He hid Christmas things in little writing.”
Weston looked at me.
I looked at the map again.
May you like
James had always made notes in the margins.
I had never once considered that one might concern Dunmore.