chronicore

Chapter 11 - I Asked Claire Why Emma Spoke

Declan’s confession answered crimes.

It did not answer my daughter.

Emma continued speaking.

Not constantly.

Not fluently.

Some mornings she returned to silence.

Other days she whispered to Claire, Harper, or Ava.

She rarely spoke to me first.

I finally asked Claire:

“Why you?”

She looked confused.

“Emma.”

Claire folded laundry at the foot of Emma’s bed.

“I don’t know.”

“You were with her after the bombing.”

“Yes.”

“She remembered your voice.”

“Probably.”

“That can't be all.”

Claire stopped folding.

“No.”

“What then?”

She sat.

“When Emma came into the ER, everyone kept asking her questions.”

Where does it hurt?

What happened?

Can you hear me?

Where’s Mommy?

“Every question required something from her.”

Claire had stopped asking.

She simply narrated what was happening.

I’m cleaning your hand.

The light is bright.

Your blanket is blue.

You don’t have to answer me.

“You did the same thing here.”

“Yes.”

I thought about the three years after Elena died.

Speech therapy appointments.

Progress charts.

Rewards.

Questions.

Can you say Dad?

God.

I looked away.

“I made talking another job.”

“You were trying to help.”

“That doesn't make it harmless.”

Claire said nothing.

I appreciated that.

No automatic absolution.

Then Emma appeared in the doorway.

“Dad?”

My head snapped up too quickly.

She almost smiled.

“What?”

She walked over.

“Don’t yell.”

“I’m not yelling.”

“You yell quiet.”

Claire looked down to hide a smile.

Apparently I had talents.

Emma climbed beside me.

Then asked:

“Mommy was leaving?”

My body went still.

Someone had spoken too freely.

Maybe Ava.

Maybe Harper.

Maybe Emma overheard.

“Yes.”

“Because of you?”

Children specialize in questions adults spend thousands of dollars avoiding.

“Partly.”

She absorbed that.

“Was she mad?”

“Yes.”

“Did she love you?”

My throat tightened.

“Yes.”

“How both?”

I looked at Claire.

She offered no rescue.

So I answered my daughter.

“People can love someone and still know they aren't safe living the same way anymore.”

Emma stared at her hands.

Then:

“Are we safe now?”

I could have promised.

Instead:

“I’m trying to make us safer.”

May you like

She nodded.

Apparently even six-year-olds understand the difference once adults stop lying.

Related Stories

Other posts