Chapter 6 - Claire Was Sick, but That Wasn’t the Whole Answer

Claire’s psychiatric evaluation did not produce the simple explanation everyone wanted.
She showed symptoms consistent with severe postpartum depression.
She also had significant anxiety and intense distress around bodily changes.
But evaluators found no evidence that she had been hallucinating or unable to understand reality during the bathroom incident.
She knew June was a baby.
She knew the act was dangerous.
She remembered what she did.
That mattered.
Her illness required treatment.
It did not turn deliberate harm into an accident.
Claire entered an inpatient perinatal psychiatric program.
I consented to nothing on her behalf.
I had no authority to make her treatment decisions unless specific legal criteria applied.
She chose to stay after the emergency hold period because, according to her doctor, she understood she needed help.
Her attorney contacted mine.
No direct communication between us.
No contact with June.
The criminal investigation continued separately.
My mother hated that distinction.
“She needs treatment, Ethan.”
“She’s getting it.”
“She isn’t a monster.”
“I didn’t say she was.”
“You’re acting like she is.”
I looked at June sleeping in the portable bassinet in my living room.
“What would you like me to act like?”
Mom cried.
I immediately felt guilty.
Then angry about feeling guilty.
Families are efficient machines for transferring emotion to whoever is still functioning.
I hired a nanny for mornings.
Reduced work to three days a week.
Turned down the next project.
Every decision was something I had promised before June’s birth.
Doing it afterward did not make the earlier promises retroactively true.
May you like
That was a hard thing to accept.
You can correct behavior without rewriting when you should have corrected it.
Related Stories